These Hiring Myths Are Costing You Top Talent

In this article...

As a hiring manager, you know that hiring top talent is essential for the growth and success of your organization. But sometimes, the recruitment process can be clouded by myths and misconceptions that can prevent you from making informed hiring decisions.      

Avoid these four common hiring myths that could stand in the way of finding your next star employee.  

Myth #1: The best candidates are actively looking for a job   

In our practice, we’ve seen that some of the best candidates may be perfectly content in their current role but would be open to a new opportunity if approached by a recruiter. Passive talent, or individuals not actively seeking new job opportunities, make up 70% of the global workforce. Given today’s nationwide talent shortage, this presents an opportunity to tap into a more extensive and diverse pool of qualified talent.   

  • Long-term retention: passive candidates are more likely to be interested in a long-term career opportunity rather than a job. They have taken time to build their current career and may consider changing it if the option is attractive enough, such as a better salary or benefits, career growth, or a different cultural fit.  
  • Competitive advantage: by considering passive candidates as part of your recruitment strategy, you can give yourself a leg up by engaging with candidates that competitors and other organizations have yet to meet.

Myth #2: A high salary is the most important factor for candidates    

The next time you’re looking to hire new talent, remember that salary is one piece of the puzzle. Today’s job seekers are looking for more than a big paycheck – they want to work for an organization that values their well-being and recognizes their contributions. Here’s why:  

  • Work-life balance and flexibility: job seekers are looking for employers who understand the importance of balance, which includes offering flexible work hours and providing creative PTO approaches to encourage taking time off and recharging.   
  • Employee recognition: recognition for a job well done is one of the best ways to keep teams motivated and engaged. Personalized incentive programs, positive feedback, and a culture of appreciation can go a long way toward building a solid team. When creating your job descriptions, make sure to emphasize these non-salary benefits.   

Myth #3: You should only hire candidates with a specific educational background  

As hiring managers, it’s easy to fall into the trap of searching for the “unicorn” candidate – someone who checks off all the boxes on the job description and has the perfect resume to match. But is firm education experience the only factor that matters when finding the ideal fit for your organization? Not anymore.  

  • Less experienced candidates can be as skilled: by focusing too narrowly on years of experience, you may be overlooking highly skilled and motivated workers who have the potential to excel in the role with the proper support and training. LinkedIn data shows that employees without a traditional four-year degree stay 34% longer than employees with such a degree. Instead of focusing on experience alone, consider tailoring the opportunity to attract candidates with the right skills, motivation, and cultural fit.  
  • Set realistic expectations when writing job descriptions: sit down with the reporting manager for the role and go over specific duties to gain a clearer understanding of the scope of the job and remove any unnecessary skills. Knowing how to write a succinct job description accurately representing the role and your organization can make all the difference in finding your next hire.   

Myth #4: You should only hire candidates who are currently working  

When looking for top talent, many employers fall for the myth that you should only hire candidates presently working.   

  • Unemployment does not equate to incompetence: unemployed candidates often face the stigma that they are less skilled or dedicated than those employed. However, many talented individuals may have left their previous job to circumstances beyond their control. Maybe they were laid off, had to care for a loved one, or were furthering their education. Others may have taken a break to recharge and take a well-deserved break.  
  • Hiring unemployed candidates can bring other benefits: for starters, they may be more open to negotiating compensation and various benefits. This can benefit your organization, particularly if you operate with limited resources or want to reduce costs. 

Successful organizations must adopt a more holistic approach to hiring, focusing on a candidate’s experience and potential, motivation, values, and cultural fit. By breaking free from these hiring myths and embracing a more open-minded and diverse approach, managers can position themselves for success in today’s rapidly evolving hiring landscape.   

Share the article:


Stay in the loop!

Receive industry updates, events, and stellar opportunities directly in your inbox!

Submit a Job Requirement

If you’re unsure what duties/responsibilities the position will entail, we can guide you through developing a comprehensive job description.

If you’re a candidate, please click here.

Need assistance?

To submit your resume and to receive alerts when a suitable position becomes available, please register with us.